By BEN MUIR
Capital News Service
LANSING — It has taken five years, four judges and three rounds in a lawsuit to decide a doping scandal between a state horse pulling association and one of its members.
And it’s still not over. A fourth round is possible.
Many thought it was over after a three-judge Michigan Court of Appeals panel ruled in favor of a Chippewa County man accused of breaking competition rules.
The case started in 2012 when a horse owned by David Esslin of Goetzville, then a member of the Bear Lake-based Michigan Horse Pulling Association, tested positive for an illegal substance. Esslin was fined and suspended from the association.
Esslin fought the drugging allegations by suing the association, successfully, for thousands of dollars.
The association banned Esslin after the lawsuit. Esslin wanted back in, so he took the group to court, where a Clare County Circuit Court judge ordered his reinstatement. The group appealed the reinstatement but lost that battle as well, according to court documents.
Esslin, 62, said he took the drugging allegations personally. As a result of the court battles, he may rejoin the association that fought for years to shun him.
“I won battle after battle,” Esslin said. “What’s right is right, and what’s wrong is wrong.”
But Esslin’s attorney, Michael Gorte of Bay City, said the association has defied the appellate court ruling to reinstate Esslin.
If Esslin isn’t a confirmed member soon, Gorte said he plans to file a motion to force the association to accept him back and to seek damages and attorney fees.
“We won at every level, yet they continue to protect him from competing,” Gorte said. “He hasn’t been able to in the last three years.”
Meantime, Esslin said the association notified him at a recent meeting that he is reinstated but it “has not cashed” any of the last two membership fees Esslin turned in.
“The association said I was reinstated but they haven’t accepted my membership fees,” Esslin said. “So no, I am not technically a member of the horse pulling club.”
Horse pulling is a competition usually found at county fairs, Esslin said. A two-horse team is trained to pull cement slabs for nearly 30 feet. Pullers have three chances before being eliminated.
If the horses make it, the process starts over but with more weight. This repeats until the horses don’t want to pull anymore. Whatever team pulls the most weight wins.
It’s a way of life for Esslin, who said his livelihood is based on competing and training pulling horses to sell. Gorte said Esslin was getting offers of up to $100,000 for the horse teams he had trained before the scandal started.
“The purse money in horse pulling is minuscule,” Gorte said. “Breeding teams is where the money is at.”
So it wasn’t just a hobby put into limbo when his horses were required to produce a urine sample in 2012, Esslin said.
The Michigan Department of Agriculture and Rural Development’s Livestock Animal Drug Testing Service found polyethylene glycol in the urine. The drug is legal, but it is often used to cover up other drugs, said Gina DeWitt, the manager of the testing service.
Three positive tests are required before DeWitt’s office will confirm a drug’s presence in urine, and polyethylene glycol was masking a second drug just enough to muddle the tests, she said. Two other tests discovered dexamethasone, a steroid that is illegal in horse pulling.
“Two tests came back positive for dexamethasone, but one came back indeterminate,” DeWitt said. “Without three positives, I call it suspicious.”
She told the association she suspected dexamethasone but couldn’t confirm it. The association requested the sample to be tested again at a different lab in Iowa, she said.
“I told [the association] what I suspected was there and then put it on the sample so they had a paper trail,” DeWitt said. “They paid for it and it is within their rights to do so.”
The Iowa lab confirmed dexamethasone.
The association fined Esslin $1,970 and suspended him for 30 days, according to court records.
Esslin sued the association for libel, saying the club shouldn’t have gone further than the Michigan test results.
“The association broke the chain of command when they sent the urine to Iowa,” Esslin said. “After the test in Michigan, the urine was probably contaminated.”
To avoid a lengthy, expensive trial, the association’s insurance company settled with Esslin for $7,500.
Association Vice President Kevin Todd said, “It costs more than $7,500 to have a trial, so the insurance company just paid Esslin to go away. That’s when we had a problem with him being in the club.”
Esslin served his suspension and paid the fine with the insurance settlement money, he said. But when he tried to rejoin, he was rebuffed, according to court documents.
His suit claimed there was an agreement in the settlement that he would be let back in if he paid his fines.
“The association took my money and then said, ‘You’re not pulling horses, we’re not letting you, we’re not selling you a membership,’” Esslin said. “They tried to bar me for life.”
But Todd said Esslin was an insurance liability, and the association couldn’t afford more court fees and higher insurance premiums.
“Esslin causes detriment to the horse pulling association and to the sport,” Todd said. “It’s not because we don’t like him. It’s not because he doesn’t win. It’s because he causes harm to the club.”
Clare County Judge Thomas Evans ordered Esslin’s immediate reinstatement. Based on the club’s bylaws, if Esslin paid the fines and served the suspension, then he was entitled to membership, according to court documents.
The recent Court of Appeals ruling confirmed Evans’ original decision.
“I never admitted to drugging my horses,” Esslin said. “But in order to pull horses again and get into that association, I had to pay the fines and penalties. The association should have accepted that and moved on.”
One negative ramification of the prolonged dispute is that horse pulling doesn’t need bad publicity, Esslin said. Interest in the sport is dwindling, and the association already has enough heartache.
“You bet I’m excited to compete again,” Esslin said. “I like beating them, and that’s what I am going to do. I am going to make them cry like babies.”
Ben Muir writes for Great Lakes Echo.